In recent times, Tesla, once the giant of the electric vehicle (EV) sector, has found itself facing a dramatic plunge in market valuation, losing a staggering $80 billion within just half an hour of tradingThis rapid decline has pushed the company's stock price to its lowest point since November 7, indicating a troubling trend that may not be easily reversedThe once-certain path to technological dominance is now clouded with uncertainties and challenges from both competitors and internal issues.
The much-anticipated "City Street Navigation" feature, developed over three years, has proven underwhelming in practical applicationsFeedback from users reveals that the system often struggles in complex driving conditions, especially at night where accuracy significantly falls below average industry standardsThis scenario starkly contrasts Elon Musk's claims of imminent fully autonomous driving capabilities, fostering skepticism among users about Tesla’s technological prowessCompounding this dilemma, rival automaker BYD has launched the "God's Eye" system with far greater efficacy, while slashing hardware costs by 30%, raising questions about Tesla's innovation strategy.
This crisis of confidence in technology is translating into a tangible loss of market share
Advertisements
In the burgeoning new energy passenger vehicle market in China, Tesla's dominance has dwindled from 18% in 2023 to just 12.7%. Furthermore, the introduction of the Xiaomi SU7, which starts at an enticing price of approximately 25,000 yuan, has directly threatened Tesla’s core customer base, with its Mobileye EyeQ5H chipset exhibiting superior performance in urban navigation tests during winterStrikingly, 28% of initial orders for the SU7 came from potential Tesla customers, indicating a significant shift in consumer sentiment.
However, the hurdles facing Tesla are not solely technologicalIn the North American market, data from the California New Car Dealers Association reveals a more profound structural issue—inventory days for the Model Y have surged from 12 days at the beginning of 2023 to 38 days now, with second-hand car depreciation rates plummeting by 19% year-on-yearThis shift underscores consumer dissatisfaction regarding Tesla's stagnation in product innovation, as competitors frequently launch 2-3 new models annually, while Tesla has not refreshed its core lineup for an alarming 42 months.
Elon Musk's forays into political ambitions have arguably exacerbated these challengesSince taking on a role in the U.S. government’s efficiency department, Musk’s public image has shifted dramaticallyHis controversial mass layoffs at federal agencies have sparked lawsuits from 14 states, and his polarizing social media comments regarding "border control" have resulted in a 34% slump in Tesla's sales in Latin AmericaMore concerning, Musk's political engagements have distracted him from managing the company effectively; in fact, his hours spent at Tesla's headquarters have decreased by 61% year-on-year in the past three months, leading to delays in the Cybertruck production timeline.
Financial reports reveal even deeper issues within Tesla
Advertisements
In its recently released fourth-quarter earnings, the automobile maker reported a meager gross profit margin of 18.6%, marking the lowest since 2021. This decline in profitability stems not only from price wars but also indicates a stagnation in production efficiency—the per-unit costs at the Shanghai Gigafactory have only diminished by 2.3% over the past 18 months, significantly trailing the 15% annual reductions observed between 2020 and 2022. Alarmingly, R&D expenditure as a percentage of total revenue has plummeted from a peak of 8.2% to just 5.1%. This figure starkly contrasts with the global automotive industry's rising R&D intensity, which has now reached an average of 12%.
Moreover, the restructuring of the global supply chain is piling on cost pressures for TeslaThere has been notable volatility in the prices of raw materials for batteries; for instance, the cost of lithium procurement from Tesla's Nevada plant surged by 47% in 2023. Additionally, the new labor laws in Mexico have led to a 22% increase in labor costs at the Monterrey plant, directly affecting pricing strategies in the North American marketThis cost squeeze is particularly evident in the European market, where the starting price for the Model 3 in Germany has risen by 15% compared to 2023, allowing competitors like Volkswagen's ID.3 to outpace it in market share.
In the capital markets, hedge funds have ramped up their short positions against TeslaAccording to data from S3 Partners, short interest in Tesla has surged to $42 billion, marking a peak not seen since 2022. This bearish sentiment is fueled not just by fundamental analysis but also reflects a broader skepticism regarding Musk's leadership capabilities
Advertisements
BlackRock's sustainable investment fund cited "systemic risks in Tesla’s governance structure," resulting in a downgrade of its ESG rating from AA to BBB.
Despite the obstacles, there remain glimmers of hope for TeslaAfter enduring 18 months of calibration, the 4680 battery production line at Tesla’s Berlin factory has finally exceeded a weekly output of 100,000 unitsThis next-generation battery technology boasts a remarkable 56% increase in energy density and a 14% reduction in costs, which, if scaled up by 2025, could fundamentally reshape the cost structure of the electric vehicle industryFurthermore, the long-speculated "Model 2" project may see a launch in the third quarter, presenting a vehicle priced around 150,000 yuan that could directly rival BYD's Dolphin and Volkswagen's ID.2.
As Tesla navigates this tumultuous period, its journey is a poignant reminder of the resilience required of modern enterprisesWhen technological innovation meets market saturation, when charismatic leadership falters in the face of governance challenges, and when cost advantages erode due to supply chain transformations, Tesla is confronted with a foundational question: can they transition from being a "tech company" to a "car manufacturer" in an era where new energy vehicles shift from being "tech-driven" to emphasizing "scale competition"?
As we look ahead to 2025, Tesla’s stock volatility is not merely a narrative of financial ups and downs; it serves as a metaphor for an entire eraWith electric vehicle penetration rates projected to exceed 35% and autonomous driving technology entering its "mass production year," this crisis may very well herald the onset of significant industry realignment.